April 23, 2019 | SAP Center, San Jose | Vegas Golden Knights vs. San Jose Sharks

Some Game 7s are remembered for their drama. Some for their overtime heroics. Game 7 of the 2019 Western Conference First Round between the Vegas Golden Knights and San Jose Sharks will be remembered for all of that—and for five of the most controversial, chaotic, and extraordinary minutes in playoff history.
What began as a seemingly comfortable 3-0 Vegas lead with 10:47 remaining turned into a bloodbath, a five-minute major penalty, four goals in 4:01, a last-minute Vegas equalizer, and an overtime winner that left one fanbase celebrating deliriously while the other screamed robbery.
When Barclay Goodrow scored 18:19 into overtime to give San Jose a 5-4 victory, it capped one of the wildest comebacks in playoff history. The Sharks became just the second team ever to overcome a three-goal deficit in the third period of a Game 7 and win—joining the 2013 Boston Bruins who did it against Toronto.
But the game will forever be defined by what happened at 9:13 of the third period: Cody Eakin’s cross-check, Joe Pavelski’s gruesome injury, a controversial five-minute major penalty that the NHL later admitted was wrong, and four power-play goals that transformed a blowout into bedlam.
The Rivalry and the Stakes
The 2019 series between Vegas and San Jose wasn’t just a playoff matchup—it was the continuation of a budding rivalry that had started intense and gotten nastier.
The previous spring, in 2018, the teams met in the second round with Vegas winning in six games en route to their improbable run to the Stanley Cup Final in the franchise’s inaugural season. That series had been chippy, physical, and filled with bad blood.
The 2018-19 regular season did nothing to cool tensions. The Sharks finished with 101 points to Vegas’s 93, earning home-ice advantage. But despite San Jose’s regular season edge, many considered the Golden Knights favorites. Sharks goaltender Martin Jones had struggled all season, posting a .896 save percentage that left many questioning whether he could win in the playoffs.
The series lived up to the hype. Vegas won Game 1 in San Jose, 5-3. The Sharks evened it with a 4-3 victory in Game 2. Vegas took Game 3, 6-3. San Jose bounced back to win Game 4, 5-0. The Golden Knights reclaimed the series lead with a 5-3 win in Game 5. The Sharks stayed alive with a 2-1 double-overtime victory in Game 6, forcing Game 7 back in San Jose.
Everything was on the line. The Sharks, desperate to advance past the first round after years of playoff disappointment. The Golden Knights, looking to prove their inaugural season success wasn’t a fluke. And 17,435 fans at SAP Center, ready to witness hockey history.
They got more than they bargained for.
Three-Goal Lead, Ten Minutes Left
Through two periods, Game 7 was all Vegas. William Karlsson scored at 5:15 of the second period to open the scoring. Cody Eakin added another at 7:13, and Max Pacioretty made it 3-0 at 18:15 of the second. The Golden Knights were dominating, Marc-Andre Fleury was sharp, and San Jose looked dead in the water.
The third period began with the Sharks desperately searching for life. They went 0-for-4 on the power play through the first 49 minutes, unable to solve Fleury or generate sustained pressure. With each passing shift, Vegas’s grip on the series tightened.
At 9:13 of the third period—with 10:47 remaining and Vegas comfortably ahead 3-0—the sequence occurred that would change everything.
The play started with a faceoff in the Vegas zone. Sharks captain Joe Pavelski won the draw against Cody Eakin. As Pavelski moved toward the puck, Eakin delivered a cross-check to his chest. The hit knocked Pavelski off balance, sending him stumbling backward into Vegas forward Paul Stastny. The collision twisted Pavelski’s body, sending him falling awkwardly to the ice.
Pavelski landed hard on the right side of his head, his helmet slamming against the ice with sickening force. He immediately went limp, motionless on the ice as blood poured from his mouth—already injured from taking a puck to the face while scoring in Game 1.
SAP Center fell silent. Brent Burns and other Sharks players surrounded their captain, frantically waving for the training staff. Joe Thornton pressed a towel against Pavelski’s head to stop the bleeding. The crowd that had been raucous moments earlier went quiet, the only sound the anxious murmurs of 17,000 people fearing the worst.
Play stopped. No penalty was initially called—neither referee Eric Furlatt nor Dan O’Halloran raised an arm during the play. But after the officials huddled, they made the call that would define the game and spark a controversy that lasts to this day.
Cody Eakin: five-minute major for cross-checking. Game misconduct. Ejected.

The SAP Center crowd roared. Vegas coach Gerard Gallant erupted in disbelief. The Golden Knights, who’d been cruising toward the second round, suddenly faced five full minutes of shorthanded hockey—and a power play doesn’t end when you score a goal on a major.
Four Goals in Four Minutes
A dazed Joe Pavelski was helped off the ice and taken to the locker room. He did not return. Blood still streamed from his mouth as he left, his status unknown. The sight of their captain being helped off the ice, blood-soaked and clearly hurt, galvanized the Sharks.
Joe Thornton, the grizzled 39-year-old veteran with nearly 1,500 NHL games under his belt, seized the moment.
“As soon as we got to the bench,” Logan Couture recalled after the game, “Jumbo said, ‘You guys go out and get f—— three goals right now.’ When a man who’s played 20 years orders you around like that, you gotta go do it.”
They got four.
Goal 1: Logan Couture at 10:01 (just 48 seconds into the power play)
Erik Karlsson’s shot deflected to Tomas Hertl, who fed Kevin Labanc, who found Couture near the left faceoff circle. Couture fired it past Marc-Andre Fleury. 3-1. SAP Center erupted.
Goal 2: Tomas Hertl at 10:50 (49 seconds after Couture’s goal)
Kevin Labanc passed from behind the net to Erik Karlsson at the point. Karlsson’s shot was tipped by Hertl, who celebrated by sliding on one knee toward the Sharks bench. 3-2. The building was shaking.
Goal 3: Logan Couture at 12:53 (his second of the power play)
A long sequence of passing ended with Labanc finding Brent Burns, who quickly fed Couture in nearly the same spot as his first goal. Couture buried it. 3-3. The game was tied. The crowd was delirious.
Goal 4: Kevin Labanc at 13:21 (4:01 into the major penalty)
Labanc, who’d assisted on the first three goals, finally got one of his own. San Jose took their first lead of the game, 4-3. SAP Center had gone from funeral silence to absolute pandemonium in less than four and a half minutes.
Four goals. Four minutes and one second. On one five-minute major penalty.

It was just the second time in NHL playoff history a team had scored four goals on a single major power play. The Sharks had erased a three-goal deficit and taken the lead with under seven minutes remaining in Game 7.
Vegas Refuses to Die
The Golden Knights, stunned by the onslaught, could have folded. Down 4-3 with under seven minutes left, having just surrendered four goals in four minutes, many teams would have crumbled under the weight of the collapse.
Vegas didn’t. They pushed desperately for the equalizer, firing shot after shot at Martin Jones. The Sharks, exhausted from their emotional explosion, tried to hold on. Jones made a spectacular glove save on Mark Stone with 3:10 remaining during a Vegas power play. San Jose was six minutes from advancing.
But with 47 seconds left in regulation, the Golden Knights tied it.

William Karlsson leaped at the blue line to keep the puck in the zone. Reilly Smith retrieved it behind the net and fed Jonathan Marchessault in front. Marchessault buried it. 4-4. The tying goal came with just 47 seconds remaining—the third-latest tying goal in a Game 7 in NHL history.
SAP Center fell silent again. After the emotional high of the four-goal rally, the Sharks now faced the crushing reality that they’d blown the lead. Game 7 was going to overtime.
Overtime: The Fourth-Liner’s Moment
The overtime period was tense, both teams exchanging chances but unable to break through. Fleury made saves. Jones made saves. Legs were heavy, nerves were frayed. As the period stretched past 10 minutes, then 15, both teams were running on fumes.
At 18:19 of overtime—with 1:41 remaining before a second overtime period—Barclay Goodrow ended it.
The fourth-line winger, who’d barely played in overtime, took a pass from Erik Karlsson and deked his way past Marc-Andre Fleury. The puck crossed the line. The red light came on.
SAP Center exploded. Sharks players poured off the bench, mobbing Goodrow. The Sharks had won 5-4. They’d overcome a 3-0 deficit in the third period of Game 7. They’d scored four goals on a controversial major penalty. They’d survived Vegas tying it in the final minute. And they’d won in overtime.
“To be honest I can’t really remember what just happened,” Goodrow said afterward. “It was a pretty surreal moment. Definitely the biggest goal of my career, obviously.”
On the other end of the ice, Vegas players slumped on their bench in disbelief. They’d led 3-0 with under 11 minutes left. They’d been 10 minutes from advancing. And now they were eliminated, victims of a controversial call and a historic collapse.
The Aftermath: Controversy and Apologies
The celebration in San Jose was euphoric, but the controversy was just beginning. Within hours, video replays showed definitively that Eakin’s cross-check had hit Pavelski in the chest, not the head. It was Pavelski’s collision with Stastny and his awkward fall that caused the injury, not a direct hit to the head.
According to Gerard Gallant, the on-ice officials told the Vegas bench they thought Eakin had hit Pavelski in the head with his stick—which would warrant a major penalty. The replays proved otherwise.
Two days later, on April 25, the NHL issued a rare apology to the Golden Knights, admitting the five-minute major was the wrong call. The league acknowledged it should have been a two-minute minor for cross-checking at most.
Furthermore, referees Dan O’Halloran and Eric Furlatt—the officials who made the call—were removed from working the second round of the playoffs, a tacit admission that they’d blown it.
But nothing could change the result. San Jose had won. Vegas was eliminated. And the controversy would linger for years.
Even Joe Pavelski, weeks later when he finally spoke to the media, admitted the call was wrong.
“Was it a five-minute major? No, I don’t think it was,” Pavelski said. “Am I glad they called it that way? Heck yeah.”
The honesty was refreshing but did nothing to ease Vegas’s pain.
The Legacy
Game 7 of the 2019 Western Conference First Round lives in infamy for different reasons depending on your perspective.
For San Jose fans, it represents one of the most thrilling comebacks in franchise history—a team rallying around their injured captain, scoring four goals in four minutes, surviving a late equalizer, and winning in overtime. The emotional arc of the game, from despair to hope to euphoria, made it unforgettable.
The Sharks would advance to the Western Conference Finals before losing to St. Louis. Joe Pavelski, who required eight staples to close his head wound, made a dramatic return in the second round. The magical run eventually fell short, but Game 7 against Vegas remained the highlight.
For Vegas fans, the game represents robbery—a properly-positioned team with a three-goal lead, eliminated by a bad call that the NHL later admitted shouldn’t have happened. The “what if” haunts them: what if Eakin gets a two-minute minor? What if the officials get the call right? What if Vegas holds that 3-0 lead for 10 more minutes?
“Last year we were in the Stanley Cup Finals and it was tough to lose,” coach Gerard Gallant said after the game. “Tonight was tougher than that. It really was, the way we lost that hockey game.”
The controversy led to immediate rule changes. The NHL implemented a system allowing officials to review major penalties—the league determining never again to let such a crucial call go unreviewed. The “Pavelski Rule,” as some called it, was a direct response to Game 7.
The Box Score
Final Score: San Jose Sharks 5, Vegas Golden Knights 4 (OT)
Scoring Summary:
Second Period
- VGK – William Karlsson (Marchessault, Theodore) 5:15
- VGK – Cody Eakin (Schmidt, Pacioretty) 7:13
- VGK – Max Pacioretty (Stastny, Reaves) 18:15
Third Period
- SJS – Logan Couture (PP) (Labanc, Hertl) 10:01
- SJS – Tomas Hertl (PP) (Karlsson, Labanc) 10:50
- SJS – Logan Couture (PP) (Burns, Labanc) 12:53
- SJS – Kevin Labanc (PP) (Kane, Couture) 13:21
- VGK – Jonathan Marchessault (Smith, Karlsson) 19:13
Overtime
- SJS – Barclay Goodrow (E. Karlsson, Hertl) 18:19
Game Notes:
- Cody Eakin assessed five-minute major and game misconduct at 9:13 of third period
- San Jose scored four goals in 4:01 on the major penalty
- NHL later apologized to Vegas, admitting call was wrong
- Second time in playoff history a team scored four goals on one major power play
- Sharks became second team to overcome three-goal deficit in third period of Game 7 (Boston 2013)
- Joe Pavelski left game, did not return (eight staples required to close head wound)
- Kevin Labanc had four assists (three on the power play)
- Logan Couture had two goals
- Attendance: 17,435 at SAP Center
Series: San Jose won 4-3
Why This Game Matters
Game 7 of the 2019 Sharks-Knights series matters because it represents everything dramatic about playoff hockey—momentum swings, controversial calls, emotional rallies, and clutch performances—compressed into 78 minutes of chaos.
The four goals in 4:01 was one of the most explosive scoring bursts in playoff history. Teams don’t score four power-play goals in four minutes against Stanley Cup-caliber opponents. It doesn’t happen. Except it did, fueled by adrenaline, emotion, and Joe Thornton’s demand for three goals.
The game also sparked legitimate debate about officiating and player safety. Should referees consider the result of a play (Pavelski’s injury) when assessing a penalty? Or should they only judge the action itself (Eakin’s cross-check)? The optics of Pavelski bleeding on the ice clearly influenced the officials’ decision—they admitted as much—but was that the right way to make the call?
The NHL’s apology and subsequent rule change acknowledged the problem: major penalties are too significant to get wrong, especially in Game 7. The league implemented video review for majors, ensuring officials could consult replay before making such consequential decisions.
For Vegas, the loss remains a painful what-if. They were the better team for 50 minutes. They built a three-goal lead. They did everything right. A questionable call on a play that maybe should have been a minor penalty—or maybe no penalty at all—changed everything.
For San Jose, the victory represents resilience and heart. Down 3-0 with their captain bleeding on the ice, they could have quit. Instead, they delivered one of the great comebacks in playoff history.
Conclusion
Game 7 between the Vegas Golden Knights and San Jose Sharks on April 23, 2019, will be debated forever. Was it an inspiring comeback or a stolen victory? A brilliant rally or a miscarriage of justice?
The answer depends on which sweater you were wearing that night.
What’s undeniable is the drama: four goals in four minutes, a last-minute equalizer, an overtime winner, and a controversy that prompted rule changes. Few games in playoff history have delivered so much chaos in such a short span.
The NHL admitted the call was wrong. Joe Pavelski admitted the call was wrong. But the result stood, as it had to—once the game ended, there was no going back.
Barclay Goodrow’s overtime goal gave San Jose a 5-4 victory and advancement to the second round. For the Sharks, it was redemption after years of playoff heartbreak. For Vegas, it was devastation—a season that should have continued, ended by a bad call and a historic collapse.
The five minutes that defined the game—from 9:13 to 13:21 of the third period—will be replayed and re-argued for as long as hockey is played. Four goals on a controversial major. A captain bleeding on the ice. A rally for the ages.
That’s Game 7. That’s playoff hockey. That’s why we watch.
—–
This is the eleventh installment in our recurring series “The Greatest Games Ever Played,” where we revisit the most memorable contests in hockey history. Check back for more legendary games that defined eras, created heroes, and showcased hockey at its absolute best.
