The Quebec Bulldogs & Hamilton Tigers

One Franchise, Two Cities, and the Strike That Ended It All

Some franchises die quietly. Others go out swinging. The story of the Quebec Bulldogs — and their reincarnation as the Hamilton Tigers — belongs in neither category. Theirs is something rarer: a franchise that produced arguably the most statistically dominant individual season in NHL history, won two Stanley Cups, suffered years of irrelevance and financial ruin, briefly resurrected itself under a new name and in a new city, then finally collapsed in the middle of what should have been its finest hour. The cause of death was a $200 pay dispute. The irony is staggering.

To trace this franchise fully, you have to start not in 1917 but in 1878 — making it one of the oldest continuously organized hockey clubs in the world — and follow it all the way to a hotel room in New York City in 1925, where a deal was struck that ended the whole enterprise for good.

Origins: Quebec City and the Game’s Early Days

The Quebec Hockey Club was founded in 1878, the same year the Quebec Skating Rink opened its doors. For the first decade it existed purely as an amateur organization, playing exhibition games against club members and visiting teams from Montreal. By 1888 it had joined the Amateur Hockey Association of Canada — one of the early formal league structures in the sport — and spent the following two decades moving through a succession of amateur and semi-professional leagues as organized hockey gradually took shape.

The club turned professional in 1908 and became a founding member of the National Hockey Association — the NHA, the direct predecessor to the NHL — in 1910. Their early NHA seasons were difficult. In 1910–11 they finished dead last, winning only four games in a sixteen-game schedule. But that miserable campaign contained a signal of things to come: a young center named Joe Malone was beginning to look like something exceptional.

The turnaround came in 1911–12. Led by Malone, the Bulldogs went from worst to first, claiming the O’Brien Cup as NHA champions and taking the Stanley Cup. They defended the title in 1913, making them back-to-back champions. For a brief window, Quebec was home to the best hockey team in the world — and at the center of it was a player whose scoring records, a century later, still have not been broken.

Phantom Joe: The Greatest Goal Scorer You’ve Never Heard Of

Joseph “Phantom Joe” Malone is one of the least-recognized transcendent talents in the history of North American professional sports. The nickname came from his ability to seemingly materialize out of nowhere in front of opposing goalies — a “careless, gliding” quality to his game that masked extraordinary precision. In an era when hockey was often played as physical warfare, Malone was notable for scoring cleanly, using positioning and timing rather than brute force.

His NHA numbers were remarkable enough: 179 goals over eight seasons, two scoring titles, two Stanley Cups. But his NHL career — compressed as it was — is where the records become genuinely surreal. When the NHL launched in 1917 and Quebec sat out its first season, Malone was loaned to the Montreal Canadiens. On the opening night of the league’s inaugural season, December 19, 1917, Malone scored five goals in a 7–4 win over Ottawa. He finished that season with 44 goals in just 20 games — a 2.20 goals-per-game average that remains the highest single-season mark in NHL history. His total held as the single-season goal record until Maurice Richard scored 50 in 1945.

“Professional hockey is a money-making affair. The promoters are in the game for what they can make out of it, and the players wouldn’t be in the game if they didn’t look at matters in the same light.” — Shorty Green, Hamilton Tigers captain, 1925

When Quebec finally rejoined the NHL for the 1919–20 season, Malone came home and did it again — scoring 39 goals in 24 games to lead the league in scoring for the second time. On January 31, 1920, playing against the Toronto St. Patricks, he scored seven goals in a single game. That record has never been equaled in over a century of NHL hockey. Malone holds or shares 13 NHL records that have never been broken, seven of which have never even been matched.

The tragedy is that the team around him was a wreck. The 1919–20 Quebec squad finished 4–20, last overall in the league. Their goaltender posted a 7.13 goals-against average — the worst in NHL history, a record that endures today. Malone was carrying a genuinely unplayable roster through sheer individual brilliance, which is simultaneously impressive and deeply depressing.

The NHL Years: Dormancy, Revival, and Ruin

The Quebec Bulldogs were founding members of the NHL in 1917, but they never actually played in it. The club’s longtime manager, Mike Quinn, had retired due to failing health. Without his organizational leadership — and without the financial backing required to field a competitive roster — the Bulldogs chose to suspend operations for the league’s first two seasons rather than put a team on the ice.

It was a decision with lasting consequences. While the Bulldogs sat out, their players were dispersed among the other clubs for $700 per man. Malone went to Montreal. Other Bulldogs were scattered across the fledgling league. The franchise retained its nominal existence, but its institutional knowledge, playing personnel, and competitive standing were largely dismantled.

Percy Quinn purchased the franchise in 1918 and worked to revive it. By December 1919 the NHL approved the Quebec Athletic Club’s application for a franchise, and for 1919–20 the Bulldogs were back on the ice. Malone rejoined them, won the scoring title, and set the single-game goals record. The team went 4–20 anyway. The NHL took the franchise back before the following season and sold it to owners in Hamilton, Ontario, who relocated the club and renamed it.

The Hamilton Tigers: Building Toward a Title

The franchise arrived in Hamilton in 1920 playing out of the Barton Street Arena, now wearing black and gold as the Tigers. The early years in Hamilton were nearly as bleak as the final year in Quebec. The Tigers went 6–18 in their first season, 7–17 in their second, 7–17 again in their third. Malone came with the franchise and remained the most compelling player on the roster, scoring 28 and 24 goals in those first two campaigns — still leading a team going nowhere.

Malone departed after the 1921–22 season, rejoining the Canadiens, and Hamilton spent the next two years grinding along at the bottom of the standings. But the roster was slowly improving. Billy Burch, a talented center who would eventually make the Hall of Fame, emerged as the team’s next franchise player. The Green brothers — captain Shorty and his younger sibling Red — brought defensive structure and leadership. Goaltender Jake Forbes began providing the kind of goaltending the franchise had never had.

By 1923–24 the Tigers finished third in the four-team NHL. In 1924–25, with two expansion franchises (the Boston Bruins and Montreal Maroons) entering the league and reshaping the competitive landscape, Hamilton had its best season by a wide margin: 19–10–1, first place overall, the best record in the league. Jake Forbes posted a 1.96 goals-against average. For the first time in the franchise’s NHL existence, the path to the Stanley Cup ran through Hamilton. The Tigers were the team to beat.

The Strike: Hockey’s First Labor Showdown

The 1924–25 season was six games longer than the previous year — the NHL had expanded the schedule from 24 to 30 games without adjusting player salaries. The Tigers’ players were under contracts that stipulated a fixed pay rate from December through late March, regardless of the number of games played. They had, in effect, played six additional games for free. Now they were being asked to play two playoff games — against the Montreal Canadiens, who had finished third — for no additional compensation either.

The Tigers players brought their case to management. They were asking for $200 each to participate in the playoffs — roughly $3,600 in today’s money — representing compensation for the extra workload the league had unilaterally added. General manager Percy Thompson declined to pay and passed the matter to NHL President Frank Calder. Calder was unmoved.

What followed was the first players’ strike in NHL history. The players held the line. Calder threatened suspension and the replacement of Hamilton in the playoff bracket by fourth-place Ottawa. Captain Shorty Green met with Calder on the day of the final semi-final game — the day Montreal eliminated Toronto to set up the Hamilton matchup — but the talks went nowhere. Calder declared the Canadiens league champions by default, suspended all Tigers players, and fined them $200 each — the exact amount they had been asking to be paid.

The symmetry is almost too neat: the players were fined precisely what they had sought to earn. Montreal went on to face the Victoria Cougars in the Stanley Cup Final, and lost. The last non-NHL team to win the Cup took the title that should, by every competitive measure, have belonged to Hamilton.

The Sale, the Apology Letters, and New York

After suspending the franchise, the NHL sold the Tigers’ player contracts to Bill Dwyer, a New York bootlegger and sports promoter, who used them to stock an expansion franchise at Madison Square Garden: the New York Americans. The players were required to write formal letters of apology to Frank Calder as a condition of being allowed to continue their careers. Shorty Green, the strike’s most visible leader, went to New York, scored the first goal in Madison Square Garden history as an American, and was eventually inducted into the Hockey Hall of Fame in 1963.

Hamilton would not return to the NHL for another five decades, and when it did — as the Colorado Rockies’ failed relocation destination in the early 1980s, a plan that collapsed — it didn’t happen then either. The city has been hockey-adjacent ever since: AHL teams, OHL teams, the persistent rumor of an NHL franchise that has never materialized. The Tigers remain, a century later, the only team in NHL history to finish first overall and then fail to play a single playoff game.

Legacy: What This Franchise Actually Was

Taken as a whole — Quebec Bulldogs through Hamilton Tigers — this franchise’s legacy is defined by the gap between what it produced and what it got credit for. It produced Joe Malone, who holds single-game and single-season records that have survived more than a hundred years of increasingly fast and skilled hockey. It won two Stanley Cups in Quebec. It built, slowly and against structural disadvantage, the best team in the NHL for one season — and then had that season taken from it by a league that didn’t think players deserved to be compensated for extra work.

The 1925 strike is worth dwelling on, because it prefigures every significant labor dispute in professional hockey that followed. The players’ argument was straightforward: the league changed the terms of the season mid-contract, added games, and kept the additional revenue. The Hamilton Tigers simply asked for their share. The league’s response — mass suspension, forced apology letters, dissolution of the franchise — was not just heavy-handed. In hindsight it was a template for the institutional approach to player labor that would recur, in increasingly elaborate form, through the NHLPA’s formation, the 1992 strike, the 1994–95 lockout, the 2004–05 lost season, and beyond.

There is something fitting in the fact that the franchise’s final act was a principled stand that cost it everything. The Quebec Bulldogs were founded forty-seven years before the NHL existed. They survived amateur league shuffles, arena fires, financial crises, two years of dormancy, a cross-province relocation, and years of league-worst records. In the end, it wasn’t any of those things that finished them. It was $200.

Teams of the Past is a RinkHive original series exploring the history of NHL franchises that no longer exist. Previous installments covered the Montreal Maroons. Future entries will include the Philadelphia Quakers, the Cleveland Barons, the Brooklyn Americans, and more.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top