Hockey’s First New York Team, the Bootlegger Who Built It, and a Rivalry That Was Never Fair
They came first. Before the Rangers dynasty, before Madison Square Garden became synonymous with New York hockey, before any of it — there were the New York Americans. They were the franchise that proved professional hockey could work in the largest city in North America. They wore star-spangled jerseys that looked like the American flag had been tailored into a sweater. Their owner was the most celebrated bootlegger in New York City. And for seventeen seasons, they served as the accidental stepping stone for a rival that would overshadow them so completely that most hockey fans today couldn’t tell you the Americans ever existed.

The story of the Americans — and their final-season incarnation as the Brooklyn Americans — is one of the most layered in NHL history. It involves Prohibition gangsters, a crooked lease, a franchise hijacking, two World Wars’ worth of economic damage, a curse that may or may not have held for fifty-two years, and a coach whose sons were killed in combat while he was trying to keep a hockey team alive in Manhattan. It ends not with a final game or a formal farewell, but with a letter in September 1942 telling Red Dutton the league would not be needing his team anymore.
The Bootlegger’s Team: Bill Dwyer and the NHL Comes to New York
The Americans’ origins run through one of the more colorful characters in the sport’s history. In 1923, Canadian promoter Thomas Duggan secured options on three NHL expansion franchises for American cities — one of which became the Boston Bruins. The New York option went to Bill Dwyer, a Hell’s Kitchen native who had built the largest bootlegging operation in New York during Prohibition, earning the nickname ‘Big Bill’ and a reputation for running his enterprise with something close to corporate efficiency. Dwyer was not a hockey man. He was a businessman who understood that a major-league sports franchise in New York City was an asset worth acquiring, and that the NHL was expanding aggressively into American markets.
The timing was fortunate in a way Dwyer could not have planned. The Hamilton Tigers, who had finished first in the NHL the previous season, had been suspended by the league after their players went on strike demanding extra pay for extra games. The entire roster was available. Dwyer paid $75,000 for the collective rights to those players — in some cases doubling their Hamilton salaries to secure their cooperation — and the New York Americans took the ice for the first time in the 1925–26 season, playing out of the newly constructed Madison Square Garden before 17,000 fans on opening night.
The uniforms alone announced that something different had arrived in professional hockey. Covered in stars and stripes patterned after the American flag, the Americans’ jerseys were a marketing statement as much as a hockey uniform — a deliberate signal that this was not a Canadian import politely visiting New York, but something born of the city itself. The 1926–27 Americans were also the first team in professional sports history to put player surnames on the back of their jerseys alongside numbers, a practice so obviously useful that the rest of the sports world eventually caught up.
The Rangers Arrive — And Everything Gets Harder
The Americans’ first season confirmed that hockey could draw in New York. They averaged over 11,000 fans per game despite finishing fifth in the league. The box office success was, unfortunately, the thing that destroyed them. Madison Square Garden management — seeing the revenue the Americans were generating in their building — immediately sought a team of their own. There was a clause in the Americans’ lease requiring them to support any such bid. The Garden had privately promised Dwyer they would never exercise it. They exercised it.
The New York Rangers entered the NHL in 1926–27, owned by Madison Square Garden, playing in Madison Square Garden, and — this is the detail that defined the next sixteen years for the Americans — managed with the full organizational resources of Madison Square Garden behind them. The Rangers won the Stanley Cup in only their second season. They won it again in 1933. From the moment the Rangers arrived, the Americans were tenants in their rival’s building, competing against a team whose landlord was also their landlord, whose scheduling conflicts the Garden could resolve in the Rangers’ favor, and whose marketing machinery made the Amerks a permanent afterthought in their own arena.
The geographic rivalry was genuine and ran deep. Dutton would later describe it plainly: the Americans had fans from Brooklyn, the Rangers had Manhattan. In a city defined by borough identity, the Americans represented outer-borough hockey against an establishment team. That division was real, and it gave the Americans a loyal if smaller constituency — but it was never enough to overcome the structural disadvantage of being a second tenant in someone else’s building.
“We had fans mostly from Brooklyn. The Rangers had the hotsy-totsy ones from New York.” — Red Dutton, Americans owner and coach
Dwyer’s Decline and the League Takeover
Bill Dwyer was convicted on Prohibition violations in 1927 and spent time in federal prison. His finances, never entirely separable from his bootlegging operations, deteriorated through the early 1930s as Prohibition ended and the Depression hollowed out his business empire. The Americans continued playing through these years — finishing near the bottom of the league more often than not — held together by a competitive if unspectacular roster that included real talent in Sweeney Schriner, who won back-to-back scoring titles in 1935–36 and 1936–37, and Nels Stewart, the Hall of Fame center who at the time held the all-time NHL goals record.

By the mid-1930s Dwyer could no longer meet his obligations to the team. He attempted to sell the franchise and found no buyers. He abandoned it. The NHL assumed control for the 1936–37 season; Dwyer sued the league, claiming they had no authority to seize his franchise. A settlement allowed Dwyer to resume control if he could pay down his debts by season’s end. He could not. The NHL took full, permanent control of the Americans after the 1936–37 season, with Schriner’s scoring title the only notable achievement from a 15–29–4 last-place campaign.
At that point the franchise might reasonably have been dissolved. Instead, the NHL handed operational control to Mervyn ‘Red’ Dutton — a former Americans defenseman who had played eleven seasons in the league and was deeply invested in keeping the franchise alive — and asked him to run the team starting in 1937–38. What followed was the most improbable run in the organization’s history.
The 1937–38 Cinderella Season
With Dutton in charge and effectively given a mandate to compete, the 1937–38 Americans assembled a roster that was, on paper, easy to dismiss. Dutton acquired veterans whom much of the league had written off: Ching Johnson, the Rangers defenseman, at 38; Hap Day, the former Maple Leafs captain; Nels Stewart, already past his prime. He paired them with Sweeney Schriner and a capable supporting cast, installed goaltender Earl Robertson — who would lead the Canadian Division in goals-against average — and built a team that finished 19–18–11, second in the four-team Canadian Division.

The playoff draw put the Americans against the New York Rangers in the first round. There was no scenario, in the mind of most observers, in which the Americans won this series. What happened instead became the defining moment of the franchise’s existence. The Americans took Game 1 in double overtime. The Rangers won Game 2 to force a deciding third game on March 27, 1938, before the largest Garden crowd of the season. The Rangers led 2–0. The Americans tied it on goals by Lorne Carr and Nels Stewart. The game went to overtime. Then another overtime. Then two more. It ended at close to 1:30 in the morning — Lorne Carr scoring the winner in the fourth overtime period — in what remains one of the most dramatic games ever played at Madison Square Garden.
The Americans advanced to face the Chicago Black Hawks in the semifinals, and came agonizingly close to reaching the Stanley Cup Final. In Game 2, Nels Stewart appeared to score what would have been the series-winning goal in the final seconds, but referee Clarence Campbell — later the NHL president — waved it off for a crease violation. Chicago survived and went on to win the Cup. The Americans had come within a disallowed goal of the Finals. It remains the closest they ever got.
The War Years and the End
The Americans made the playoffs in each of the next two seasons — losing in the first round to Toronto in 1938–39 and to Detroit in 1939–40 — but the structural pressures were compounding. Canada entered World War II in September 1939, and Canadian players began leaving for military service in significant numbers. The Americans, whose roster was built heavily around Canadian players, were hit harder than most. By 1940–41, with a decimated lineup and Dutton still carrying debt inherited from the Dwyer era, the Americans went 8–29–11 — the worst record in franchise history — and missed the playoffs entirely.
Dutton’s personal losses during this period were devastating. Two of his sons were killed in the war. He was simultaneously trying to keep an underfunded, talent-depleted hockey franchise operational in the most expensive city in North America while burying his children. That he continued doing so at all is a testament to something that defies easy categorization.

In a last attempt to find a new identity and a new fan base, Dutton renamed the franchise the Brooklyn Americans for the 1941–42 season and announced plans to move the team to Brooklyn — where the Americans had always drawn their most passionate support. There was one problem: there was no arena in Brooklyn capable of hosting NHL hockey. The Brooklyn Americans practiced in Brooklyn and played their home games at Madison Square Garden, the building owned by their rivals. It was a rebrand without a home, and it fooled nobody. The team finished 16–29–3, last in the league, and suspended operations after the season for the duration of the war.
The NHL’s Broken Promise and the Dutton Curse
The suspension was intended to be temporary. Dutton had every intention of returning the Americans to the ice after the war ended, and the NHL had made assurances — informal but explicit — that reinstatement would be granted. By 1945, a group had emerged willing to build a new arena in Brooklyn specifically to house the returning franchise. The pieces, improbably, seemed to be coming together.
In 1946, the NHL reneged. The franchise was formally canceled. Dutton blamed Madison Square Garden ownership — which also owned the Rangers — for lobbying the league to eliminate the competition rather than allow the Americans to return and challenge the Rangers’ monopoly on New York hockey. Whether or not that account is accurate in every detail, it is consistent with every structural dynamic that had defined the franchise’s existence: the Rangers’ landlord had always held the power in this relationship, and they used it one final time.
Dutton’s response was, depending on your level of credulity, either a colorful piece of sports folklore or one of the stranger documented phenomena in North American professional sports. He purportedly swore that the Rangers would never win the Stanley Cup again in his lifetime. The Rangers had won in 1928, 1933, and 1940. They did not win again until 1994 — seven years after Dutton’s death in 1987. Fifty-four years without a championship. The ‘Dutton Curse’ was never officially acknowledged, but Rangers fans of a certain age knew exactly what it was.
Legacy: What the Americans Actually Were
The New York Americans never won the Stanley Cup. They finished first in the league exactly once — never. They were last-place finishers in nine of their seventeen seasons. By almost every conventional competitive metric, they were a failure.
And yet the franchise’s legacy is more substantial than the standings suggest. They were the first NHL team in New York City, and their box office success in 1925–26 directly triggered the league’s decision to place a second franchise at Madison Square Garden — a decision that created the New York Rangers, one of the most storied franchises in hockey history. Without the Americans proving the New York market, there is no Rangers dynasty. Without the Rangers dynasty, the NHL’s American expansion of the late 1920s might have looked very different. The Americans were the proof of concept that the rest of the league’s American growth was built on.
The franchise produced genuine talent, too. Sweeney Schriner won two scoring titles and was inducted into the Hockey Hall of Fame. Nels Stewart, who joined the Americans late in his career, had held the all-time NHL goals record and was a Hall of Famer. Red Dutton himself was inducted as a builder in 1958. The 1937–38 team’s run remains one of the more compelling Cinderella stories in playoff history, and the four-overtime win over the Rangers in the deciding first-round game is the kind of moment that would be replayed endlessly if it had happened to a franchise that survived.
What the Americans were, more than anything, was a franchise that existed in the wrong building under the wrong ownership structure in the wrong era. They were first to New York but second in their own arena. They were the scrappy outer-borough team in a city that rewarded the establishment. They were built by a bootlegger, run into the ground by debt, temporarily resurrected by a man who lost his sons in a war he was watching from a hockey bench, and then quietly canceled by a league that had found them inconvenient.
The Original Six era began the season after Brooklyn suspended operations. The Americans are not counted among those six. They are instead the franchise that made New York a hockey city, got none of the credit, and left behind a curse that took half a century to lift.
Teams of the Past is a RinkHive original series exploring the history of NHL franchises that no longer exist. Previous installments covered the Montreal Maroons, the Quebec Bulldogs/Hamilton Tigers, and the original Ottawa Senators/St. Louis Eagles. Future entries will include the Philadelphia Quakers, the Pittsburgh Pirates, and more.
